Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Tim Mitchell
REALTOR®,
Branch Manager/Partner, CRB, GRI
Chairman's Club 2022

Customer Reviews

Tim is always polite, courteous and knowledgeable. I've worked with Tim on several properties, and he has been a joy to work with on each one. I highly recommend Tim.

Fran | Home Buyer

Tim Mitchell is friendly and dependable and patient.

John Rosevelt, Decatur | Home Buyer

Tim has taken care of all of our previous sales in the area over the years. We can depend on Tim to get the most value out of our property. He comes to the first meeting with ideas and a plan. He follows through with any and all questions. Tim goes out of his way to make sure we are happy with every thing. We use no other realtor to handle our real estate needs.

K & B, Dowagiac | Home Seller

Tim has been a great resource over the many years we have bought and sold real estate over the years. I have always had a great deal of respect for Tim in how patient he had been with us. We would absolutely recommend Tim based on his knowledge and care and the time he invested in us.

Roger Goranson | Home Buyer

Carmen, Tim, and I came up with a plan to sell two houses in a given timeframe, they did exactly what they said they would do, can't beat that.

Matt Demaj, Sister Lakes | Home Seller

Tim is easy to talk to and has a great personality. He makes the stress of home buying more fun. His knowledge of the real estate world it extensive and his advice extremely valuable.Carmen was an amazing agent and worked with us every step of the way. She was always on time and available for any questions we had. She notified us immediately when the house we wanted fell out of contract and we were able to resubmit our offer. She was also able to orchestrate a same day close of the sale of our previous house and the sale of our new home. Carmen’s hard work allowed us to have a positive home buying experience and because of her we got the house we wanted! It was a dream home buying experience everything seemed to just fall into place. Our great home buying experience is directly due to our amazing team. Thank your for your hard work.

Corryn Napier | Home Seller

Great job getting deal done!

Tom Chapleau, Newport Beach, CA | Home Buyer

This is the third home I have been involved with purchasing from Tim. He is the BEST! I would recommend him without question to other potential buyers.

Sue Ireland, Chicago | Home Buyer

I always enjoy working with Tim. Very knowledgeable and great Attention to detail!

Syndie Cassedy | Home Buyer

Tim knows the area and the market. There was no one else I was interested in. I called him to list my house and that was it.Tim was extremely pleasant and easy going. He knows his business and answered all questions. He is a genuinely kind person and just wanted to make the sale of our house go as smoothly as possible which it did!This was an incredibly easy sale. Tim and his team handled everything. They were extremely professional and got me exactly what I wanted.Everyone I worked with at Tim’s office was extremely professional and pleasant to work with. They were always ready and able to answer any questions.We have bought and sold real estate over the past 25 years and this was the easiest of all real estate transactions. This was all due to the wonderful knowledge and expertise of Tim and his staff.

L Gabriel- Burr Ridge IL | Home Seller

Very pleased with how nice they were to work with and how fast they were able to sell my property

Mary Snyder, Dowagiac | Home Seller

Our experience dealing with Tim and his staff was excellent, we would recommend Tim Mitchell to family and other friends

Joe and Brenda Camalick, 19149 Wentworth Ave. Lansing IL., 60438 | Home Seller

Excellent job by Tim Mitchell. I strongly recommend him.

Thomas Vana | Home Buyer

Tim is the MAN! He is very knowledgeable and polite and accommodating- He made the process very easy and enjoyable-Nick Patti-

Nick Patti | Home Buyer

Tim Mitchell was extremely knowledgeable about the local area and went above and beyond what was needed to sell the property. We believe he was instrumental in finalizing the sale. Carmen Fleischauer, who assisted Tim, responded to our multitude of questions, promptly and efficiently. Carmen made the process pleasant and "painless" and we enjoyed our time working with her. We would highly recommend both of these individuals to anyone selling in the Sister Lakes area!!

Cathy B. Sister Lakes | Home Seller

Great agent and extremely knowledgeable on the area. I lived the experience working with Tim and team

Jeff, Chicago | Home Buyer

Tim is very knowledgable and an expert in his field. The whole team was great to work with and the process was very smooth.

Kelly Pehler; Gurnee | Home Seller

Great agent and extremely knowledgeable on the area. I loved the experience working with Tim and team

Jeff, Chicago | Home Buyer

He did a good job

William Scherer sister lakes Michigan | Home Seller

Tim was respectful and very knowledgeable in the entire process, which was important and helpful for me.

Catherine West Coloma | Home Seller

no complaints

gmarr, Kalamazoo | Home Buyer

I could not have been more happy with all of my dealings and interactions with Tim! I felt very comfortable during the whole process as Tim was always approachable, knowledgeable and very helpful! I would recommend Tim to family and friends looking to purchase a home!

Don Popp, Palos Heights, IL. | Home Buyer

Tim and his staff did everything they could with a difficult sale of a older manufactured home. Tim went over and beyond helping this sale finally get thru. Thanks to Tim and his staff on behalf of our whole family.

Mark O'Meara Willow Springs Illinois | Home Seller

Tim was very professional and a pleasure to work with.

Joseph P. Vrdolyak II - Dowagiac, MI | Home Buyer

Tim Mitchell is a true professional and master in his field. His understanding and insight of the local market is second to none.

Pat Nugent, Chicago | Home Buyer

Professional, knowledgeable agent. Very important part of my selection criteria. He demonstrated very good listening skills as well. His follow-up was excellent and he met his deadlines/time commitments. I could trust Tim.

Gary Giltner | Home Seller

I would recommend Tim Mitchell again. He was always available and a pleasure to work with.

Judy Neuman | Home Buyer

Tim is a true professional who puts his clients requirements and needs above his own. He was a pleasure to do business with. I’m confident we will become friends in the future.

Lou Cassara, Naperville IL | Home Buyer

Tim and his staff were great. Tim worked closely with us and advised on pricing and sales startegy. He always answered or returned calls quickly. At closing, a small issue came up, Tim went above and beyond in taking care of it. I highly recommend Tim for his hard work and honesty. I would definitely use his services for both buying and selling.Thank you, to Tim and Carmen. Well done.

Greg Ehman, Frankfort IL. | Home Seller

Tim was extremely helpful and knowledgeable, not only regarding the properties but also in regards to the local area. I would highly recommend time to anyone looking to purchase a lake property.

John Kronenberger - Dowagiac | Home Buyer

Tim is the best. I would recommend him to anyone who is interested in buying or selling in Sister Lakes.

John Shanahan | Home Seller

very knowledgeable on area and values and how to make the transaction smooth

scott langer | Home Seller

Tim knows the local real estate market and community. He does a great job connecting buyers with property, and working through the complexities of real estate transactions. He has successfully sold multiple properties for me.

Don, SIster Lakes, MI | Home Seller

Tim and Carmen assisted me on the purchase of my home on Magician Lake. The entire process went very smooth. I was impressed with their knowledge of the Sisters Lakes area. I would highly recommend Tim and Carmen. Thank you again.

Bill from Magician Lake | Home Buyer

Tim is very knowledgeable about current treaty conditions as well as activities in the area.

Charles Stancik , Palos Hils, I'll. | Home Seller

Tim was great to work with.

Lori Whittingham, Dowagiac/Sister Lakes | Home Seller

Perfect transaction and highly recommended

Brenda Parker | Home Seller

Tim did everything in his power to get us the best deal on our house. He went the extra mile multiple times to give us a great experience buying our first house. He found us everything on our list that we wanted in a house. He is a great!

Tony, Lawrence | Home Buyer

All went as well as expected.Thank you!

Chris Christerson 51196 3rd St | Home Buyer

great experiance

c mielke cassoppolis | Home Buyer

very happy with the entire experience,wished it had happened much earlierConnie Bohn, Dowagiac

Connie Bohn Dowagiac mi | Home Seller

Tim Mitchell was very helpful in our lake home purchase. His knowledge of the area and people he works with made the process go smoothly. Tim meet with all inspectors, handled all paper work and helped with the county officials. My wife and I could not be any happier with the purchase. He is just a genuine good guy.

Dan and Diane Nowaczyk Magician Lake | Home Buyer

Tim Mitchell and his staff did an excellent job marketing our home. His knowledge of the Sister Lakes area was very help full in putting together a plan to sell our home. I would recommend Tim Mitchell and his staff if you are planning to buy or sell a property in the Sister Lakes MI area.

Jerry Crandall, Frankfort IL | Home Seller

Comments listed in survey is best discription testimonial!

David Fritz. Lawrence Mi | Home Seller

Tim went way above and beyond the call of duty to take care of me. Which I think is just the way he does business. And it's appreciated. Would recommend him to anyone which by the way I've done already.

Corey McPherrin Chicago | Home Buyer

Easy to work with.

BRS Dowagiac, MI | Home Seller

I am so appreciative of the wonderful service we received from Tim! He knew we were interested in a lakehouse on a non-motorized lake and contacted me immediately when the perfect house became available. We loved the house as soon as we saw it. The entire process of purchasing the home was seamless and non stressful. We now own this beautiful home and look forward to enjoy it for years to come.

Tim knows the area and the market. There was no one else I was interested in. I called him to list my house and that was it. Tim was extremely pleasant and easy going. He knows his business and answered all questions. He is a genuinely kind person and just wanted to make the sale of our house go as smoothly as possible which it did! This was an incredibly easy sale. Tim and his team handled everything. They were extremely professional and got me exactly what I wanted. Everyone I worked with at Tim’s office was extremely professional and pleasant to work with. They were always ready and able to answer any questions. We have bought and sold real estate over the past 25 years and this was the easiest of all real estate transactions. This was all due to the wonderful knowledge and expertise of Tim and his staff.

Lori Gabriel

Tim is very knowledgeable and an expert in his field. Tim and his team were incredibly efficient and expedient . The whole team was great to work with and the process was very smooth.

I could not have been happier with all of my dealings and interactions with Tim! I felt very comfortable during the whole process as Tim was always approachable, knowledgeable and very helpful! I would highly recommend Tim to family and friends looking to purchase a home!

Tim was great! He was extremely professional and knowledgeable and made the home buying process stress-free. I would definitely recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Tim Mitchell was very helpful in our lake home purchase. His knowledge of the area and people he works with made the process go smoothly. Tim meet with all inspectors, handled all paper work and helped with the county officials. My wife and I could not be any happier with the purchase. He is just a genuine good guy.

6 years ago I met Tim while I was looking for property in the lakes area. I called to see a property and he was there 10 minutes after that call. I was quite surprised that he was there so quickly. The property however was not what I was looking for. In 2016 I found the property I was looking for and called to ask if Tim would be my contact for the property since he was so helpful the first time I met him. He took care of me and the process of getting that property. I was quite satisfied with how he set everything up for me. I have been coming to Sister lakes area since 1960 when I was 7 years old so we both know a lot about the area. It was nice sharing stories about our knowledge of the area and things we remember through the years and how the area has changed since the 1960's. Much has changed but a lot of things are still the same and it is nice to know someone who has been there as long as I have been going there. I would recommend Tim to anyone who is looking for property in the area if you want someone who really does know the area and will take all the time needed to help find your dream vacation home. Now I am a happy vacation home owner and I have no complaints about the process. I am completely happy about my choice having Tim do my business for me.

Tim was very helpful in selling my home. The recommended price was on point as multiple showings were scheduled within the first couple days of listing and a full price offer was received within the first week of listing. Tim coordinated minor repairs that needed to be done coming out of the home inspection. Tim made it a very easy process to sell my house.

Tim began with an accurate analysis of the market and our house, and made a fairly bold commitment on a selling price, which he then negotiated and got for us in a challenging market. I recommend him to anyone buying or selling in the area.

Tim is extremely knowledgeable of the area. He has gone FAR above and beyond what a typical realtor would do in making our home purchase a reality, including contacting vendors to obtain bids on work needed in the home, meeting the vendors at the home to provide quotes, and even showing us how to use our boat. This entire home purchase process would have been far more complicated had he not been involved and we greatly appreciate it.

Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 11/30/2022. The listing information on this page last changed on 11/30/2022. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Wed 11/30/2022 11:17:09 PM EST) or GNIAR MLS (last updated Wed 11/30/2022 11:04:52 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Wed 11/30/2022 11:11:37 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved. --

Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Tim Mitchell is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Michigan.

Login to My Homefinder

Login to My Homefinder