Get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Tim Mitchell
Chairman's Club 2025
REALTOR®, Managing Broker/Partner, CRB, GRI
(269) 208-9425
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon YouTube Icon Pinterest Icon Instagram Icon Yelp Icon Realtor.com Icon Zillow Icon google Icon realsatisfied Icon 

If you're thinking about selling your home, look no further. Tim Mitchell is the ABSOLUTE BEST. His knowledge, professionalism, communication skills and overall Real-estate experience is EXTREMELY IMPRESSIVE. We couldn't be more satisfied with the TIM MITCHELL TEAM at Cressy and Everett - Sister Lakes.

Jeff and Diane Chancey, Ave Maria, Fl | Home Seller

If you're thinking about selling your home, look no further. Tim Mitchell is the ABSOLUTE BEST. His knowledge, professionalism, communication skills and overall Real-estate experience is EXTREMELY IMPRESSIVE. We couldn't be more satisfied with the TIM MITCHELL TEAM at Cressy and Everett - Sister Lakes.

Jeff and Diane Chancey, Ave Maria, Fl | Home Seller

Tim: Sold the house in days for top dollar. Knows his stuff and was very helpful along the way.

Bob Summers, Chicago | Home Seller

Tim did a great job with the real estate portion but went well above and beyond when our house developed a water leak while we were out of state. He and his team did the initial cleanup and contacted insurance and contractors to handle the repairs.

Tim went above and beyond with his service for us. We had an unexpected water leak emergency while we were out of town that he fortunately discovered. He and his associates handled the initial clean up as well as coordinated insurance and construction repair to get that problem taken care of. Definitely well above requirements of a realtor!

Neil Lesh, South Bend, Indiana | Home Seller

We have worked with Tim and his crew on a few different properties in the last few years. Nothing but compliments! They have done a fantastic job at marketing the properties to the right buyer. He is honest and true to his word in every way. I would heartily recommend Tim! We will absolutely use his services again in the future.

Scott Stambaugh, Watervliet MI | Home Seller

We have worked with Tim and his crew on a few different properties in the last few years. Nothing but compliments! They have done a fantastic job at marketing the properties to the right buyer. He is honest and true to his word in every way. I would heartily recommend Tim! We will absolutely use his services again in the future.

good fast procedure and closing

Jim Neubauer, Decatur Michigan | Home Buyer

It was a pleasure to work with Tim Mitchell on the Sister Lakes property. Tim is very personable and has a wealth of knowledge about the area as a veteran realtor. Tim made the process simple and fast and was key in expediting the sales process. He was pleasant, communicative and stayed on top of the timeline, so we actually closed earlier than expected! We will definitely choose Tim for our future real estate transactions.

Janel Bartlett and Tim Parker, Sister Lakes, MI | Home Buyer

I had an excellent experience working with Tim and Caroline. They were incredibly knowledgeable about the local market and guided me through every step of the process with patience and professionalism. I truly felt like they had my best interests at heart and were always looking out for me. I highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in Southwest MI specifically Sister Lakes.

Linzy Kling, Sister Lakes | Home Buyer

I was impressed by their knowledge of the area and their exoertise of the whole process.

Jack Pieroth, Elmhurst, Il. | Home Seller

We have worked with Tim in the past. Very knowledgeable and transparent. Enjoy working with Tim. Would highly recommend him.

Alison Goranson, Dowagiac, MI | Home Buyer

It has been a long 10 months trying to close a deal, after one deal fell through because of circumstances beyond ours or Tim's control. Although Tim is related to us, his professional, knowledgeable and honest communications were appreciated. He was aware of our circumstances and worked very hard and creatively to close the deal. Tim's expertise in the real estate market is an attribute that everyone should consider and he is well recommended in our view.

Mark Heeter, Dowagiac, MI | Home Seller

Tim's knowledge of the property he represented was a huge plus!

Dennis Carrico, Granger, In | Home Buyer

Had a very good experience with Tim , and he and staff were viligant in showing my home to buyers almost daily .. Very happy that I went with Tim Mitchell , and his experience .. Thank you Tim ...!!!

James Cullen, Palos Heights , IL. | Home Seller

Tim was very easy to work with and helpful in preparing the house for listing. He always communicated with me in a timely manner. I would highly recommend Tim Mitchell.

Virginia Cardoza, Glencoe, IL | Home Seller

Tim is professional and very knowledgeable about lake homes in Dowagiac Mi. He answered our questions and returned phone calls and texts quickly!! His appraisal for our home was spot on, and we sold our home very quickly. We highly recommend Tim, as well as his coworkers Caroline and Carmen! We appreciated working with Tim and his team! Thanks, Tim for you good service!

Gloria L., Dowagiac, Mi | Home Seller

Tim is professional and very knowledgeable about lake homes in Dowagiac, Mi. He answered our questions and returned phone calls and emails quickly. His appraisal for our home was spot on, and we sold very quickly. We highly recommend Tim, and his coworkers Caroline and Carmen! We appreciated working with Tim and his team. Thanks, Tim for your great service

No one knows the Sister Lakes area as well as Tim Mitchell. With the help of him and the rest of his team, my brother and I got a great deal for a place we'd only ever dreamed of having!

Walker O’Brien, Dowagiac, MI | Home Buyer

Tim was very knowledgeable and very helpful and in all aspects

Steve Sankowski, Mokena Il | Home Seller

We actually worked with Carmen F. And experience was excellent. Kept us informed of what was happening at all times. Was efficient, understanding and kind throughout the process. Thankful for the privilege to work with her and would highly recommend her to anyone.

Michael Robinson, Barrington, IL | Home Seller

Tim, Caroline and Carmen were absolutely fantastic in every detail!! There were mulitple complications on contingency needs with 3 closings in one day. If one piece fell...the domino effect would have been a huge problem. Tim and his crew did a lot of behind the scenes work to make everything work out flawlessly. Nothing but high marks for the entire staff! Highly recommend!!

Scott Stambaugh, Dowagiac, MI | Home Seller

Tim, Caroline and Carmen were absolutely fantastic in every detail!! There were mulitple complications on contingency needs with 3 closings in one day. If one piece fell...the domino effect would have been a huge problem. Tim and his crew did a lot of behind the scenes work to make everything work out flawlessly.Nothing but high marks for the entire staff! Highly recommend!!

Tim is very knowledgeable and professional. He is willing to go above and beyond to do his job well and make his clients happy. I would definitely recommend Tim to everyone selling property in Southwest Michigan!

Sharon, St. Joseph, Mi | Home Seller

Tim and his team are great. They take the time and effort to make sure you understand all aspects of your property and are just plesant to do business with.Really apprecaite him taking some time ti take us on a boat ride around the lake and share some ideas about the house we are building. Truly one of a kind.

Sean M Giblin, Lemont, Illinois, United States | Home Buyer

Very helpful and knowledgeable. Enjoyed working with Tim.

Kevin And Eileen, Sister Lakes | Home Seller

Tim is the best realtor you could ever ask for. He is knowledgeable, friendly, honest, and has an excellent grasp of how to get a deal done equitably and in short order. He has a thorough grasp of his market area and all of the contacts necessary to facilitate an effective closing for both seller and the buyer. We've had previous contact and related experiences with Tim in the past years, and there's no one better in our experience that we've ever worked with anywhere. We'd recommend him to anyone who desires to buy or sell property in the Benton Harbor, St. Joseph, and Dowagiac areas of southwestern Michigan.

Don DeGraff, Sister Lakes, Michigan | Home Buyer

Tim worked with me and explained all phases of marketing and sales. Would recommend him to anyone interested in a complete real estate experience.

Guy M. Jamnik, Sister's lake's mi. | Home Seller

Tim Mitchell was a joy to work with, every step of the way. He returned all of our phone calls promptly and was a great listener. We would highly recommend him to help make selling or buying a home an effortless experience.

Laura Ellis, Nokomis FL | Home Seller

Tim is an excellent partner in real-estate dealings and very good at what he does. We have now bought and sold homes leveraging his expertise and were very impressed with his knowledge, responsiveness and commitment. Highly recommend working with him as he really understands the market well and will help secure the best outcome in the area.

Tim Mitchell and Carmen were excellent and professional! Loved working with them both! Very, very professional and knowledgeable with Sister Lakes area! Thanks for all your help!!!

Jackie Ogarek, Chicago, IL | Home Seller

Tim did everything in his power to make this sale work. It ws a pleasure working with him.

Jim McGovern, Downers Grove, ILL | Home Seller

Tim and his whole team were amazing throughout. Great communication with explainations along the whole process. I loved how Tim, Carmen, and Caroline all had a group chat with my my husband and myself. Made communication super easy and fast. They were always so responsive and helpful with any questions we had. Great group to partner with when selling a home.

Morgan | Home Seller

Our realtor was Carmen Fleischauer and she is amazing!! When we decide to sell our family cottage, at the recommendation of a friend, we called Carmen. From our first appointment, to the closing she was nothing but helpful, knowledgeable and supportive. The cottage sold immediately and what we thought would be quick process, required lots of time and patience to get through probate. Carmen was pretty terrific and helped us throughout the whole process.

Nancy Tunney | Home Seller

Tim is always polite, courteous and knowledgeable. I've worked with Tim on several properties, and he has been a joy to work with on each one. I highly recommend Tim.

Fran | Home Buyer

Tim Mitchell is friendly and dependable and patient.

John Rosevelt, Decatur | Home Buyer

Tim has taken care of all of our previous sales in the area over the years. We can depend on Tim to get the most value out of our property. He comes to the first meeting with ideas and a plan. He follows through with any and all questions. Tim goes out of his way to make sure we are happy with every thing. We use no other realtor to handle our real estate needs.

K & B, Dowagiac | Home Seller

Tim has been a great resource over the many years we have bought and sold real estate over the years. I have always had a great deal of respect for Tim in how patient he had been with us. We would absolutely recommend Tim based on his knowledge and care and the time he invested in us.

Roger Goranson | Home Buyer

Tim is easy to talk to and has a great personality. He makes the stress of home buying more fun. His knowledge of the real estate world it extensive and his advice extremely valuable.Carmen was an amazing agent and worked with us every step of the way. She was always on time and available for any questions we had. She notified us immediately when the house we wanted fell out of contract and we were able to resubmit our offer. She was also able to orchestrate a same day close of the sale of our previous house and the sale of our new home. Carmen’s hard work allowed us to have a positive home buying experience and because of her we got the house we wanted! It was a dream home buying experience everything seemed to just fall into place. Our great home buying experience is directly due to our amazing team. Thank your for your hard work.

Corryn Napier | Home Seller

Carmen, Tim, and I came up with a plan to sell two houses in a given timeframe, they did exactly what they said they would do, can't beat that.

Matt Demaj, Sister Lakes | Home Seller

Great job getting deal done!

Tom Chapleau, Newport Beach, CA | Home Buyer

I am so appreciative of the wonderful service we received from Tim! He knew we were interested in a lakehouse on a non-motorized lake and contacted me immediately when the perfect house became available. We loved the house as soon as we saw it. The entire process of purchasing the home was seamless and non stressful. We now own this beautiful home and look forward to enjoy it for years to come.

I always enjoy working with Tim. Very knowledgeable and great Attention to detail!

Syndie Cassedy | Home Buyer

This is the third home I have been involved with purchasing from Tim. He is the BEST! I would recommend him without question to other potential buyers.

Sue Ireland, Chicago | Home Buyer

Tim knows the area and the market. There was no one else I was interested in. I called him to list my house and that was it. Tim was extremely pleasant and easy going. He knows his business and answered all questions. He is a genuinely kind person and just wanted to make the sale of our house go as smoothly as possible which it did! This was an incredibly easy sale. Tim and his team handled everything. They were extremely professional and got me exactly what I wanted. Everyone I worked with at Tim’s office was extremely professional and pleasant to work with. They were always ready and able to answer any questions. We have bought and sold real estate over the past 25 years and this was the easiest of all real estate transactions. This was all due to the wonderful knowledge and expertise of Tim and his staff.

Lori Gabriel

Tim knows the area and the market. There was no one else I was interested in. I called him to list my house and that was it.Tim was extremely pleasant and easy going. He knows his business and answered all questions. He is a genuinely kind person and just wanted to make the sale of our house go as smoothly as possible which it did!This was an incredibly easy sale. Tim and his team handled everything. They were extremely professional and got me exactly what I wanted.Everyone I worked with at Tim’s office was extremely professional and pleasant to work with. They were always ready and able to answer any questions.We have bought and sold real estate over the past 25 years and this was the easiest of all real estate transactions. This was all due to the wonderful knowledge and expertise of Tim and his staff.

L Gabriel- Burr Ridge IL | Home Seller

Very pleased with how nice they were to work with and how fast they were able to sell my property

Mary Snyder, Dowagiac | Home Seller

Our experience dealing with Tim and his staff was excellent, we would recommend Tim Mitchell to family and other friends

Joe and Brenda Camalick, 19149 Wentworth Ave. Lansing IL., 60438 | Home Seller

Excellent job by Tim Mitchell. I strongly recommend him.

Thomas Vana | Home Buyer

Tim is the MAN! He is very knowledgeable and polite and accommodating- He made the process very easy and enjoyable-Nick Patti-

Nick Patti | Home Buyer

Tim Mitchell was extremely knowledgeable about the local area and went above and beyond what was needed to sell the property. We believe he was instrumental in finalizing the sale. Carmen Fleischauer, who assisted Tim, responded to our multitude of questions, promptly and efficiently. Carmen made the process pleasant and "painless" and we enjoyed our time working with her. We would highly recommend both of these individuals to anyone selling in the Sister Lakes area!!

Cathy B. Sister Lakes | Home Seller

"Tim is very knowledgeable and an expert in his field. Tim and his team were incredibly efficient and expedient. The whole team was great to work with and the process was very smooth."

Kelly Kepehler | Home Seller

Tim is very knowledgeable and an expert in his field. Tim and his team were incredibly efficient and expedient . The whole team was great to work with and the process was very smooth.

He did a good job

William Scherer sister lakes Michigan | Home Seller

Tim is very knowledgable and an expert in his field. The whole team was great to work with and the process was very smooth.

Kelly Pehler; Gurnee | Home Seller

Great agent and extremely knowledgeable on the area. I loved the experience working with Tim and team

Jeff, Chicago | Home Buyer

Great agent and extremely knowledgeable on the area. I lived the experience working with Tim and team

Jeff, Chicago | Home Buyer

Tim was respectful and very knowledgeable in the entire process, which was important and helpful for me.

Catherine West Coloma | Home Seller

I could not have been happier with all of my dealings and interactions with Tim! I felt very comfortable during the whole process as Tim was always approachable, knowledgeable and very helpful! I would highly recommend Tim to family and friends looking to purchase a home!

Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 04/25/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 04/25/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Sat 04/25/2026 8:51:02 AM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Sat 04/25/2026 8:47:46 AM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Sat 04/25/2026 8:44:50 AM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Sat 04/25/2026 8:48:31 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Tim Mitchell is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Michigan.

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel